The Liberty Tree Initiative
First Amendment Day was made possible by a grant from the Liberty Tree Initiative. The Liberty Tree Initiative is an informal coalition of educators, journalists, librarians, artists and authors with a shared interest in building awareness of the First Amendment through education and information. The goal is to bring enlightening and thought-provoking programs to college campuses across the country. The Liberty Tree Initiative campus program is made possible by the support of the McCormick Foundation and the First Amendment Center.

On Thursday, Oct. 1, 2009, UNC-CH celebrated First Amendment Day. This campus-wide, day-long event was designed to both celebrate the First Amendment and explore its role in the lives of Carolina students. Students and others read from banned books, sang banned music and discussed the importance of each of the rights protected by the First Amendment, the need to be tolerant when others exercise their rights and the public university's special role as a marketplace of ideas. First Amendment Day was co-sponsored by the UNC Center for Media Law & Policy and the Campus Y. Below are the highlights of the events, press mentions, photos and videos from First Amendment Day.
First Amendment Day Events
Click here to view the full schedule of First Amendment Day events
First Amendment Day Buzz
“Bring on the Debate,” by Meredith Engelen, The Daily Tar Heel, Oct. 7, 2009
The Daily Tar Heel piece followed up on two First Amendment Day events, the panel discussion titled, “The State of Free Speech at Carolina: A Conversation with Haley Koch, Nikhil Patel and Hugh Stevens,” and the keynote lecture delivered by Greg Lukianoff, “Unlearning Liberty.” The article concluded with this mandate to campus: “There are ideas we like and ideas with which we vehemently disagree. But at our great University, these ideas become lessons of tolerance, patience and, ultimately, lessons in the freedom to decide for ourselves.”
Click here to read the full article
Click here to read all the First Amendment Day Buzz
First Amendment Day Photos
Click here to view the First Amendment Day Photo Gallery
First Amendment Day Videos
Coming soon: First Amendment Day Video Gallery
First Amendment Day Buzz
“Celebrate our freedoms: First Amendment Day serves as a reminder of the freedoms afforded by the Constitution,” by Editorial Board, The Daily Tar Heel, Oct. 1, 2009
This piece discussed the various rights protected by the First Amendment and urged students to participate in the activities on campus.
Click here to read the full post
“First Amendment Day!” by Chris Higginbotham, Chris Higginbotham: Blog, Oct. 1, 2009
UNC School of Journalism and Mass Communication graduate student Chris Higginbotham blogged about his appreciation for the First Amendment after attending several events on campus.
Click here to read the full post
“First Amendment Day!” by Park Library staff, JoMC Park Library Blog, Oct. 1, 2009
The staff at the Park Library in the School of Journalism and Mass Communication blogged about displaying books that celebrated all of the First Amendment protections and attending First Amendment Day’s kick-off event, the tree planting outside of Carroll Hall.
Click here to read the full post
Norfleet, a School of Journalism and Mass Communication student, discussed the demonstration organized by the Carolina Association of Black Journalists. The event was designed to show how African Americans protested the violation of their First Amendment right during the Civil Rights Movement.
Click here to read the full post
“Students read banned books, tape mouths for First Amendment Day,” by Julian Caldwell, The Daily Tar Heel, Oct. 1, 2009
This post discussed the scene in The Pit as students gathered for the banned book reading as well as the demonstration organized by the Carolina Association of Black Journalists.
Click here to read the full post
“A good day for the 1st Amendment,” by Leroy Towns, Talk Politics Blog, Oct. 2, 2009
Towns, a professor at the UNC School of Journalism and Mass Communication, discussed several themes that emerged during First Amendment Day, including “two messages of optimism for free speech on campus along with one warning.”
Click here to read the full post
“Patel, Koch speak civilly,” by Neena Vasavan and Colleen Volz, The Daily Tar Heel, Oct. 2, 2009
This article covered the panel discussion between Haley Koch, Nikhil Patel and Hugh Stevens regarding the spring 2009 Tancredo protests. The article highlighted the civil tone of the discussion between the panelists and discussed each panelist’s take on the situation.
Click here to read the full article
"We're all catchers in the rye," by Holden Thorp, Office of the Chancellor Blog, Oct. 2, 2009
Chancellor Thorp discussed why he chose to read Catcher in the Rye when he kicked off the banned book reading in the Pit during First Amendment Day.
Click here to read the full post
“Panel Discussion: ‘The Rights and Responsibilities of Carolina’s Student Media,’” by Anika Anand, Inside Carolina Journalism, Oct. 3, 2009
Anand, a senior in the School of Journalism and Mass Communication, discussed the First Amendment Day panel featuring the editors of the Daily Tar Heel, Carolina Review and Campus BluePrint.
Click here to read the full post
“Bring on the Debate,” by Meredith Engelen, The Daily Tar Heel, Oct. 7, 2009
The Daily Tar Heel piece followed up on two First Amendment Day events, the panel discussion titled, “The State of Free Speech at Carolina: A Conversation with Haley Koch, Nikhil Patel and Hugh Stevens,” and the keynote lecture delivered by Greg Lukianoff, “Unlearning Liberty.” The article concluded with this mandate to campus: “There are ideas we like and ideas with which we vehemently disagree. But at our great University, these ideas become lessons of tolerance, patience and, ultimately, lessons in the freedom to decide for ourselves.”
Click here to read the full article
“Welcoming the Clash of Ideas,” by Jay Schalin, Clarion Call, The John William Pope Center for Higher Education Policy, Oct. 14, 2009
This article discussed four recent campus events, including First Amendment Day, that reflected an increase in tolerance toward conservative viewpoints on the UNC campus. Discussing First Amendment Day, the article noted, “The highlight of the day was a panel ‘debate’ featuring the only student arrested for participating in the Tancredo protest, Haley Koch, and the current president of the YWC, Nikhil Patel."
Click here to read the full article
“Agree to disagree: free speech means letting everyone talk,” by MaryAnn Barone, Blue & Whitin’, Oct. 18, 2009
This post, from the blog run by the staff of Blue & White magazine, discussed Lukianoff’s keynote lecture and the Tom Tancredo protest. Barone encouraged students to be more open to listening to conflicting and opposing viewpoints.
Click here to read the full post
First Amendment Day Events
Tree Planting, 9 a.m.
As the kick-off event for First Amendment Day, a UNC Liberty Tree was planted in front of Carroll Hall, home to the School of Journalism and Mass Communication. Cathy Packer, faculty director of the UNC Center for Media Law and Policy; Richard Harrill, director of the Campus Y; and Dean Jean Folkerts of the School of Journalism and Mass Communication each spoke briefly. Then Student Body President Jasmin Jones read the First Amendment. Members of the audience joined in to help plant the tree. There was a “UNC Liberty Tree” sign on the tree (an elm) and a Carolina blue bow on the shovel.
Student a cappella groups sang banned music in the Pit (the place in the center of campus where students gather during the day) between classes. One group sang a medley of rap songs; another sang a Madonna song.
Cubes on Campus, Throughout the day
Large painted cubes located near the Campus Y were available for students to write on and express their thoughts about free speech.
First Amendment Books, Throughout the day
The Park Library in the School of Journalism and Mass Communication displayed books that explain and explore the First Amendment. Featured books included Abandoned in the Wasteland: Children, Television, and the First Amendment by Newton Minow, Freedom for the Thought that We Hate: A Biography of the First Amendment by Anthony Lewis and Tolerance and the First Amendment by Lee Bollinger. For a complete list, please visit: http://www.worldcat.org/profiles/jomcparklib/lists/1048745.
Step Up! Speak Out, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.
The Campus Y organized soap boxes for students to stand up on and exercise their right to freedom of speech on the topic of their choice.
Banned Book Reading, 12:30 to 2 p.m.
Campus leaders and others read from banned books in The Pit. As part of this event, Chancellor Holden Thorp read an excerpt from Catcher in the Rye. At the same time, a selection of banned books was displayed in The Pit. This event was organized by Erica Eisdorfer of the Bulls Head Bookshop, Lisa Norberg of the University Library and School of Library and Information Sciences graduate student Maggie Hargrave.
The Civil Rights Movement Moves the First Amendment, 1:45 to 2:15 p.m.
Student members of the Carolina Association of Black Journalists organized a demonstration of the ways African Americans pushed back when they were denied First Amendment freedoms during the Civil Rights Movement in America. Students taped their mouths shut and held signs referencing historic Supreme Court cases from that period. Information sheets about these cases were provided.
The Rights and Responsibilities of Carolina's Student Media, 4 to 5 p.m.
A panel of Carolina’s student journalists – editors from the Daily Tar Heel, the student-run campus newspaper; Carolina Review, a monthly conservative journal; and Campus BluePrint, a new publication of the UNC Young Democrats – discussed their rights, their responsibilities and whether they are fulfilling their responsibilities. Panelists took questions from the audience and engaged in a lively conversation about their editorial processes and decisions. The panel was moderated by Andy Bechtel, assistant professor in the School of Journalism and Mass Communication, and was organized by senior religious studies major Bryan Weynand, who is the editor of Carolina Review.
Civil Rights Walk, 4 p.m.
The Black History Walk was an event presented to teach the history of the struggle for Civil Rights on UNC's campus and in the surrounding Chapel Hill community. Beginning in the Pit, the tour, conducted by Professor Tim McMillan of the African and Afro-American Studies Department, highlighted sites such as Franklin Street’s Chapel of the Cross, where a slave balcony still exists. Local community members talked about their experiences in Chapel Hill, the history of the fight for equality on Franklin Street and how the struggle continues to this day as local developments threaten the integrity of working and middle-class communities in Chapel Hill. The event was organized by the UNC-Chapel Hill Chapter of the NAACP, United with the Northside Community-Now (UNC-NOW) and Students for the Advancement of Race Relations (SARR) for a Black History Walk.
The State of Free Speech at Carolina: A Conversation with Haley Koch, Nikhil Patel and Hugh Stevens, 5:30 to 6:30 p.m.
This panel discussion between Haley Koch, Nikhil Patel and Hugh Stevens covered the First Amendment issues raised by the protest against former Congressman Tom Tancredo’s speech last spring on campus. Haley Koch, a UNC senior and activist, was arrested for her role in the protest that prevented Tancredo from speaking in Bingham Hall. The case against Koch was thrown out by a judge on Sept. 14, but as a result of the publicity generated by the charges, Koch has repeatedly been threatened and harassed. Nikhil Patel is a UNC senior and the president of Youth for Western Civilization, the conservative student group responsible for organizing the Tancredo speech. YWC has struggled to remain a viable campus group since being stigmatized as a white supremacist group by more liberal students; the organization recently lost its faculty adviser for the second time since the Tancredo speech. Hugh Stevens is a nationally known First Amendment and media lawyer who served as general counsel for the North Carolina Press Association for 20 years and continues to serve as counsel to the North Carolina Press Foundation, the North Carolina Open Government Coalition and several North Carolina newspapers, including The News & Observer. Steven’s interest in the First Amendment began as a student at UNC-CH in the 1960s. During the discussion each panelist shared his or her perspectives of the Tancredo incident and the First Amendment implications of the protest; the state of free speech on the UNC campus more generally was also discussed during this dialogue. Panelists then participated in a question-and answer-session with members of the audience. The event was organized and moderated by senior journalism and mass communication major Sam Wardle.
Unlearning Liberty, 7 to 8 p.m.
Greg Lukianoff, president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), delivered the keynote lecture. Lukianoff reported on the state of the First Amendment on American college campuses and stressed the importance of the free exchange of ideas on campus. Lukianoff said: “[T]he censored of one generation too often become the censors of the next. Our ultimate goal is to break this sad and predictable cycle and prove that students at America’s colleges and universities are strong enough and smart enough to live with truly free and open debate.”
Story Time – With Milk and Cookies, 8:30 to 9:30 p.m.
The UNC Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender, Straight Alliance (GLBTSA) and the Lambda Law Students Association discussed children’s books that have been banned from libraries because they have gay and lesbian themes. The books included And Tango Makes Three by Peter Parnell and Justin Richardson and King and King by Linda De Haan and Stern Nijland. Members of Lambda Law Students Association provided the censorship history of each of these banned books. Then members of the GLBTSA read the stories aloud while the audience enjoyed freshly baked cookies and milk.
First Amendment Day Photos
| Spectators at the Tree PlantingMembers of the UNC community gathered near the steps of Carroll Hall to the kick off First Amendment Day. |
| Jasmin Jones Reads the First AmendmentJasmin Jones, student body president and senior in the School of Journalism and Mass Communication, read the text of the First Amendment aloud. |
| Dean Folkerts Helps Plant the UNC Liberty TreeDean Jean Folkerts of the UNC School of Journalism and Mass Communication pitched in to help plant the UNC Liberty Tree. |
| Banned Book ReadingCampus celebrities, including Chancellor Holden Thorp, read from banned books in The Pit during lunchtime. |
| Students Examine Banned Book DisplayStudents stopped by to look at the display of banned books in The Pit. |
| Students Gather to Listen to ReadingsStudents gathered to listen to books that were banned throughout the years. |
| Student with Mouth Taped ShutAs one part of the demonstration, students taped their mouths shut to symbolize the suppression of free speech during the Civil Rights Movement.
|
| Students Hold Signs Signifying Important Supreme Court DecisionsStudents in The Pit displayed signs regarding important Civil Rights Era Supreme Court decisions related to the First Amendment. |
| Students Receive Information on Court DecisionsInformation sheets about the Court decisions referenced on the signs were handed out in The Pit during the demonstration. |
| Stevens Discusses Free Speech at UNCStevens, a UNC alum, explained the First Amendment issues surrounding the protest of the Tancredo speech. |
Photos by UNC seniors Wendy Thigpen Holmes and Reiley Wooten and UNC School of Journalism and Mass Communication faculty members Jock Lauterer and Ruth Walden.
























